Several clear signs indicate replacement is the better choice. If you’re seeing water marks on your siding, gutters pulling away from your house, or basement flooding after typical Long Island storms, repair won’t solve the underlying issues.
Gutters that sag, have multiple leaks, or show rust damage throughout the system are telling you they’ve reached the end of their useful life. In coastal areas like Mastic Beach, salt air exposure accelerates deterioration—what looks like minor damage often extends throughout the entire system.
The cost difference between extensive repairs and full replacement is often minimal, but replacement gives you decades of worry-free performance versus temporary fixes that need attention again within a few years.